The Answer Standard
Truth, then meaning, then a way to act
The fixed five-layer shape every consequential Atlas Commons answer is built to — each layer with an explicit epistemic guarantee.
When you ask Atlas Commons a question where being wrong is expensive, the answer is built to a fixed
five-layer shape — and each layer carries an explicit epistemic guarantee. The recorded fact, the warrant
that makes it legible, the comparison that never becomes a ranking, the route to the official source, and the point
where a human must take over. It is the answer-level companion to the Public Knowledge Charter
(the binding rules) and the per-claim research object (the citation).
1 · Truth →2 · Meaning →3 · Options →4 · Action →5 · Escalation
The five layers
Layer 1
Truth — the recorded fact
A source-backed figure, traced to a named dataset and carried as a research object with its four-status warrant. Never a vibe, an estimate dressed as a fact, or a number without a source.
Guarantee Every figure is traced to a named public source. On the decision surfaces that carry the research object it also carries a machine four-status warrant (RECORDED / MODELED / DERIVED / INTERPRETATION). A model is never presented as the source.
Layer 2
Meaning — the warrant that makes it legible
The framing a non-expert needs to read the fact correctly: what it is, what it is not, and the caveat that prevents a wrong decision. A bare number can mislead; the meaning layer is correctness, not decoration.
Guarantee The caveat that would change a decision is stated before the number, not buried after it.
Layer 3
Options — compare, never rank
The set of real choices, presented so they can be compared on the figures — never ordered into a “best.” Atlas Commons informs and compares; it does not pick for you, because the right choice depends on facts only you hold.
Guarantee No “best,” no payout-ordered ranking (Charter, Article 4). The comparison is on provenanced figures, side by side.
Layer 4
Action — the route to the official source
The concrete next step at the authoritative source — where the decision is actually made or the transaction actually happens. The atlas hands off; it never pretends to be the endpoint.
Guarantee Every consequential answer routes to the official surface (HealthCare.gov, Medicare.gov, the courts, the FDA…), never to a sale or a sign-up of ours (Charter, Article 5).
Layer 5
Escalation — when a human takes over
The boundary past which only a person — a doctor, a lawyer, a licensed advisor, the official agency — can responsibly act, stated plainly. The atlas names its own edge.
Guarantee The answer says where it stops. No diagnosis, no legal or financial advice, no per-person verdict from an aggregate (Charter, Article 10).
A live answer, read in five layers
Ask the Coverage Atlas “What will an ACA plan cost me in Texas?” — a question where being wrong is expensive. The
live answer is shaped exactly to the standard:
Truth
A typical Silver plan costs $762/month for a 40-year-old — the DERIVED median over the RECORDED CMS Marketplace Rate PUF premiums (sticker rates, source id src:cms:aca-rate-puf:2026). The underlying rates are recorded; the median across them is a derived statistic — labeled as such, never dressed up as a single official number.
Meaning
Read these as sticker prices, not your price — the full premium before income-based tax credits; most enrollees pay far less. Stated above the number, not after it.
Options
The full metal-tier table — Bronze / Silver / Gold median and range — to compare, side by side. No “best plan,” no ordering.
Action
“For your actual price, enter your income at
HealthCare.gov” — the official marketplace, where enrollment actually happens.
Escalation
“This atlas informs and compares — it is not advice on which plan to buy.” Net cost depends on your situation; the marketplace and a licensed broker take over.
The same shape holds across the network: the Justice Atlas reports a district's civil docket (RECORDED counts, DERIVED shares), bounds it as volume-not-quality, and routes to the courts and to counsel; the Coverage Atlas pairs an insurer's spending ratio with the rebate it owed and routes to Medicare.gov.
What the standard forbids
A ranking sold as truth. Ordering options into a “best” is an opinion, not a fact — Layer 3 compares, it never decides.
Advice sold as a fact. A per-person verdict drawn from an aggregate (your risk, your odds, your diagnosis) crosses into Layer 5 and is withheld.
An action with no route. A consequential answer that does not hand off to the official source is a dead end — or a trap that keeps you on our surface.
A truth with no source. A figure that cannot be traced to a named dataset is a rumor; it does not ship. On a decision surface, no figure ships without its four-status warrant.
Why this is a standard, not a footnote
Because it is machine-readable and uniform. An agent that has read this standard knows the shape of
every answer in the commons before it fetches one: where the sourced fact is, where the caveat is, that the
options are compared and not ranked, where the official route is, and where the answer stops. That is what lets an AI
cite an Atlas Commons answer responsibly — and what lets a person trust one. Fetch
/answer-standard.jsonld for the structured spec.