Public goods
A public good is architecture, not an adjective
Free access isn't enough. Measured against the Digital Public Goods standard — honestly, factor by factor — with a defined public core and a paid edge that never touches the truth.
Free access is not automatically a public good. A free website can still be proprietary, fragile, uninspectable, surveillance-funded, pay-to-rank, removable at the owner's whim, impossible to reuse, or locked to one closed platform. So public good has to be an architectural property — something you can check against a standard — not a marketing claim. This page measures Atlas Commons against that bar, honestly.
Free access is not automatically a public good
A free website can still be:
- proprietary — the data and methods are closed
- fragile — one outage or one owner away from gone
- uninspectable — you can't see how a number was made
- surveillance-funded — the user is the product
- pay-to-rank — money buys a better answer
- removable at the owner's whim — no continuity guarantee
- impossible to reuse — no open license, no export
- platform-locked — dies if one closed platform changes terms
Public good must be an architectural property, not a marketing claim.
Measured against the Digital Public Goods standard
The Digital Public Goods Alliance standard
is the external benchmark — we measure ourselves against it rather than asserting the label. Today:
4 met, 2 partial, 1 committed.
Open licensing
Meets The content and data are released under an open, reusable license.
Every research object — the page, the .jsonld, the .md/.toml/.context.md — is released CC0 (public domain). The normalized factual data, the schemas, and the provenance metadata are openly licensed wherever upstream source terms allow.
Clear ownership
Committed Ownership of the assets is documented and accountable.
Today Atlas Commons is operated by a single operator. The Public Knowledge Charter and the governance design commit the mission assets — the marks, methods, schemas, correction histories — to a nonprofit Foundation that holds them outside the commercial entity. That transfer is staged, not yet executed; it is a dated commitment, not a present fact.
Platform independence
Partial The good does not depend on a single closed platform; it can be re-hosted.
The data is portable by construction — CC0, standard schema.org/Markdown/TOML formats, content-hashed exports, stable entity identifiers — so it can be re-hosted by anyone. But it currently runs on one host (Cloudflare); true multi-platform redundancy is not yet in place. The openness makes exit possible; it is not yet exercised.
Documentation
Meets The methods, sources, and structure are documented well enough for others to use and reproduce.
The methodology, the research-object model, the provenance & citation guide, the source manifests on every figure, and the /llms.txt orientation are all published. Per-dataset documentation deepens as each atlas matures.
Privacy & do-no-harm
Meets It collects no unnecessary personal data and is designed to avoid foreseeable harm.
Atlas Commons indexes only already-public authoritative datasets; it collects no personal data and requires no login to read. Consequential pages carry an explicit boundary — a reference figure, not advice — and route a worried person to the primary source and a qualified human.
Security
Partial Reasonable security practices protect the service and its users.
The surfaces are static, read-only, served over HTTPS behind a major edge network's DDoS protection; there is no user data to breach. A formal third-party security review has not yet been conducted — hence partial, not met.
Open standards & interoperability
Meets It uses open standards so machines and other tools can interoperate.
Every entity is published as schema.org JSON-LD plus open Markdown / TOML / JSON, projected from one definition. The four-status warrant vocabulary is open and documented. An agent or a competing index can consume it without permission.
The public core
These stay free, ungated, stable, and accessible:
- canonical factual answer pages
- source citations and source manifests
- methodology, definitions, and taxonomies
- basic comparisons
- official and free next-step options
- dataset versions and freshness
- correction records
- funding and conflict disclosures
- stable entity identifiers
- baseline machine-readable exports (.jsonld / .md / .toml / .context.md)
- a reasonable-use public API surface
- accessibility-compatible pages
- archival and shutdown provisions
Openly licensed too, where upstream terms allow
- normalized factual data
- schemas
- provenance metadata
- source registries
- selected ingestion tooling
- selected interface components
The paid edge
The commercial entity may charge for scarce resources — never for the truth layer:
- personalization
- computation at scale
- monitoring and alerts
- urgency
- human judgment
- implementation and integrations
- workflow execution
- representation
- guarantees and SLAs
- high-volume API access
It may never charge for, gate, or alter the public facts, rankings, methodology, or corrections — that boundary is
the separation of powers and the charter.